You are here

Yelp, Gowalla, foursquare, Urban Spoon etc. are walled garden data silos of Doom that don't provide useful recommendations

Submitted by Roland on Sat, 2011-04-16 21:05

Part 1 of Rant - Recommendations from Yelp, foursquare, etc  are useless because there's no way to validate expertise and no identity

social+local+expert data = relevant recommendations aka Yelp, Foursquare, urban spoon, etc are walled garden data silos of doom NOT destiny and they don't really help you find the awesome restaurant  or espresso g*d shot you are looking for despite Fred Wilson's experience (an exception that proves the rule)

Part 2 of Rant - Don't trust your review data not to be compromised and not to be deleted when using a service like Yelp, foursquare, etc

You may be elite-2011-taster-273487 on yelp or urban spoon but or other such location based or recommendation based service, but:

  1. you don't own your data e.g. your reviews
  2. you can't export your data
  3. why should anybody believe that it's you or trust your reviews when it's impossible to figure out who you are e.g. who is JudyS_240394 ?
  4. your data will be sold (only Apple seems to have the guts not to sell user data)
  5. what happens when the wonderful service goes out of business or "pivots"? 

Part 3 of Rant - Solutions - for now: copy to your site, future: open formats are the only long term way to get out of the silo

It's unfortunate that in 2011 that the best way to build up a consistent reputable, verifiable, track record for reviews or anything else that's structured beyond mere text is still to to have your own site e.g. a blog .

The best pragmatic compromise is to somehow copy the data you post in walled garden data silos of doom back to a site you control on your domain (unfortunately most walled garden sites don't allow you to get your data out without compromise; exceptions that prove the rule: flickr and instagr.am)

Or flip it around: Make your site the master and copy the data out to walled gardens like twitter, yelp, facebook etc is probably a better short term pragmatic solution. Not surprisingly the usual suspects :-) like Dave Winer and Tantek are pioneering this (check out Tantek's falcon system).

And in the long term, a "beyond unstructured blog of text" open API or data format for things like reviews which we have been discussing since 2004 (e.g. microformats) will actually happen. I remain optimistic about that :-) !

Comments

I think Urbanspoon is the only one that took the aggregation approach. I'd like to see more of this federated-by-default approach, but it seems like the sites that people are using as their home base are actually getting less capable of hosting / integrating that sort of approach.

Hello! I just want to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you have here on this blog. I will be coming back aimed at your website for additional soon. this

No matter how many times I read it, it never gets old. You definitely hit the nail on the head on this one. I was searching something like this. I want to get more from you. thunder-link

electric things turn into one of the fundamental requires that must be owned or operated by you will see throughout hargamesinterbaruku.blogspot.com. Additionally, with the electric things we could help save power along with help to make your body wholesome, well being data is it possible to learn throughout http://situsmedis.blogspot.com that features a great deal to offer well being data, besides the newest data exclusive dna may look at seribuinfounik.wordpress.com data or even smart dataphone newest latest throughout info smartphone terbaru although it is also however a lot of web-sites which go over the latest data such as infosekarang.tumblr.com. Never to forget about at this point barnag electric data such as mesin jahit can be quite very much inside lookup with the important jobs pertaining to firms like the a single throughout usahasekarang.weebly.com/. At this point any office perform turns into less difficult due to mesin absensi which often can help save hard work. An data ought to be dispersed for you to many people like throughout fullsharing.bravesites.com in particular regarding is important with regards to kesehatan. Not only had been the info technological innovation, seeing that shown throughout sharingfull.blogdetik.com is perfect throughout looking at pertaining to information on smartphone android are actually growing available all over the world.

stunning, incredible, I was wondering how to cure skin inflammation regularly. furthermore discovered your site by google, took in a ton, now i'm a bit clear. I've bookmark your site furthermore include rss. keep us overhauled... "fort myers criminal lawyer"

App2.TV provides free and open streaming applications to play your video from any PC, notebook, tablet or smartphone to The Big Screen for best entertainment on TV. TV App

To get more bookings for your B&B you need an integrated booking system. This encourages your website visitor to book there and then and stops them shopping for other accommodation. We supply B&B reservation software that facilitates live online bookings to your B&B. All online bookings placed are then subject to your approval. Pos45

This review may be slightly different in nature than other reviews of Loyal 9 but it is the same in one regard - that it gives 5 stars for expertise and excellent.loyal 9 complaints

Took personal time to peruse all the remarks, yet I truly reveled in the article. It turned out to be Very useful to me and I am certain to all the commentators here! It's generally decent when you can be educated, as well as entertained! car listing

 

HP LaserJet printers offer advanced security management features that keep up with your changing needs, so you can always print with peace of mind. if you need the driver printer, you can check at Click Here HP LaserJet printers, MFPs and JetAdvantage solutions empower users to do more in less time. An innovative suite of mobile printing options, security solutions and manageability tools help you streamline workflows so you can keep pace with the demands of your growing business. if you need the driver printer, you can check at Click Here Note 3 neo beats them both by a mile. It has a stylus, AMOLED screen and all the phablet features such as multi window and other s-pen features. if you need the gadgets info, you can check at read more the Aventador is the flagship coupe (or roadster) in the Lamborghini stable. Only one powertrain exists: a 6.5-liter, 691-hp V-12 mated to a seven-speed automatic transmission and all-wheel drive. if you need the last info about car automotive, you can check at read more Search engine optimization (SEO) is the process of affecting the visibility of a website or a web page in a search engine's "natural" or un-paid ("organic") search results. if you need the last info update about technology, you can check at Click Here The PIXMA MP250 gives consumers great quality at a great value all in one compact, stylish machine. Print, Copy and Scan as well as print beautiful borderless1photos up to 8.5" x 11" with true photo lab quality. if you need more info about geophysics, you can check at read more

Pages

Add new comment